Sometimes you want to go “au natural” when controlling pests in your garden or yard, and only an organic product will do. However, sometimes non-organic products are best—and not necessarily unfriendly to the environment.
For example, some non-organic bark sprays are better at permeating the tree (not the air around it), which is an eco-friendly approach without being technically organic. Foliar sprays might come with an organic label, but when they’re being released into the air, suddenly they’re not as green as you’d like.
So, organic or not organic? There are pros and cons to either approach, and it’s important that landscapers, gardeners and contractors choose wisely. Consider this your cheat sheet to picking the best product for you, your landscape, and the environment.
Pro: (Sometimes) Better for the Environment
You may be able to lighten your carbon footprint, depending on the product and application. According to numerous studies, including from Montana University’s Agricultural Department, chemical pesticides stick around in the atmosphere longer than organic options. They also linger in waterways and in the soil well after the application is made. This can lead to a lot of collateral damage—organic pesticides may minimize environmental impacts.
Pro: Better for the Soil
Studies have also showcased that farmers who used chemical pesticides later saw a big change in soil health. Between 1940 and 1991, it’s estimated by the US government that trace minerals (the good stuff) in fruits and vegetables fell by over 75 percent due to unhealthy soil. Soil isn’t just necessary to simply grow plants, fruits and veggies, but it also contributes directly to the nutrients that you and your family might be depending on. Organic pesticides can help soil remain healthy—and that’s passed down to you and your dinner plate.
Pro: A Healthier You
According to studies published in the Pesticides Literature Review journal, chemicals have been strongly linked to a number of diseases and chronic illnesses. Cancer, reproductive problems and nervous system ailments have all been connected to the use of chemical pesticides. Childhood conditions are especially prevalent, such as leukemia, asthma and neurological disorders.
Con: They’re More Costly
Anyone who’s debated the organic banana vs. the “regular” one at the grocery store knows that going organic is often going to cost you. However, only you can make the call if it’s worth it or not for you and your needs. Think of the big picture and what you really want to accomplish.
Con: They’re Not Always as Effective
Chemical approaches to pest management became so popular because they’re cheap, fast and they work. Organic approaches might not always be as effective, but that’s also not always the case. Read reviews, get expert help and make sure you’re tackling pests the right way for the best results.
Con: They Might Take Longer
In the world of construction, it’s often said that you can only have two of three things: Speed, quality or low cost. Some might say the same is often true of organic pest management. Yes, chemical pesticides work at lightning speed—but at what cost? Some organic approaches might take a bit more time, but it’s worth it for some.
When choosing organic vs. non-organic options, keep an open mind and consider what end result you’d most like.